Tata Technologies Bears Brunt Of VinFast Revenue Decline — Should Investors Be Worried?

Tata Technologies has a lot of client concentration, which could be a key downside, according to JPMorgan.

Tata Technologies Ltd. (Source: Company website)

Tata Technologies Ltd. listed on the bourses on Dec. 1, 2023. And while the stock made a stellar debut, it has underperformed in the last nine months.

The global engineering services company offers product development and digital solutions. The company's listing was one of the best debuts on the Indian market, with the stock surging 180% over the issue price.

So what went wrong?

Also Read: Tata Technologies Shareholder Offloads Stake Worth Rs 1,230 Crore

VinFast: The Troublesome Deal

The company has till date reported three financial results after its listing. While the third quarter of fiscal 2024 was seasonally soft, as mentioned by the management, the fourth quarter was impacted by a decline in the revenue of VinFast, one of its largest clients.

Even though the company reported a 6% increase in the profit for the third quarter, the stock closed marginally lower by 0.5% the day after the results were announced.

In the fourth-quarter earnings call, the company said that the decline in VinFast revenue would affect the first quarter of fiscal 2025 as well, while there would be a marginal impact on the second quarter also.

In the first quarter, the management said the VinFast transition was behind now and the business was expected to pick up from the second quarter.

The company has a lot of client concentration, which could be a key downside, according to JPMorgan.

Business Segments 

Tata Technologies is primarily focused on the automotive industry and is currently engaged with seven out of the top 10 automotive engineering, research and development spenders and five of the top 10 prominent new energy engineering, research and development spenders.

The company broadly operates in two segments—services and technology solutions.

The company provides outsourced engineering services and digital transformation services to global manufacturing clients to help them conceive, design, develop and deliver better products.

Its technology solutions segment has two parts: products and education. Through its products business, it sells third-party software applications, primarily product lifecycle management software and solutions. It also provides services such as consulting, implementation, system integration and support. 

Through its education business, it provides 'phygital' education solutions in manufacturing skills, including upskilling and reskilling public and private sector employees in the latest engineering and manufacturing technologies through its iGetIT platform.

Tata Technologies gets around 78% revenue from the services business and balance from the technology segment.

Also Read: Tata Technologies Confirms Termination Of Chhattisgarh ITI Upgrade Project

On Margins

The company's Ebit margin stood at 15.9% in the first quarter of fiscal 2025, compared to 16.2% in the third and fourth quarters of fiscal 2024.

Tata Technologies expects the margins to increase 200 to 250 basis points in the medium term, though a specific timeline was not given.

Stock Price Movement 

Tata Technologies stock is listed at Rs 1,200 per share, which is a 140% premium over its issue price band of Rs 475 to Rs 500 per share. It rallied another 17% and took the total gains to 180% over its issue price on the listing day. The IPO was subscribed 69.43 times on its final day.

However, over time, the stock has been volatile. It hit the lowest level of Rs 976 per share on Aug. 5. It has since pared losses, closing at Rs 1,076.40 per share as of Sept. 5. However, this is still below its listing price.

Analysts' Recommendations

Of the 10 analysts tracking the company, three have a 'buy' rating and seven suggest a 'sell', according to Bloomberg data. The 12-month analyst consensus price target implies a potential downside of 13.9%.

ICICI Securities Ltd. has a 'buy' rating on the stock with a target price of Rs 1,290 per share. Tata Technologies has an edge over its peers because of its partnerships with marquee names that limit the downside from ramp down in VinFast, the brokerage said after attending its analyst meet. It values the company at a price to earnings ratio of 56 times, based on 12 month forward earnings per share.

Also Read: Tata Technologies - ICE-To-EV Prowess, SDV, Plant Engineering To Drive Growth: ICICI Securities

lock-gif
To continue reading this story
Subscribe to unlock & enjoy all
Members-only benefits
Still Not convinced ?  Know More
Watch LIVE TV , Get Stock Market Updates, Top Business , IPO and Latest News on NDTV Profit.
GET REGULAR UPDATES